• Re: Doctor Who 73 yards review with spoilers

    From suzeeq@21:1/5 to Arthur Lipscomb on Sun May 26 21:39:30 2024
    XPost: rec.arts.tv

    On 5/25/2024 4:42 PM, Arthur Lipscomb wrote:
    On 5/25/2024 11:56 AM, The Doctor wrote:
    Doctor Who's latest episode weaves a tangled and intriguing narrative
    that
    takes viewers from the rugged coast of Wales to the future political
    arenas
    of Cardiff. As always, the Doctor (played with aplomb) finds himself
    entangled in a complex web of time and mystery. This time, the web
    is literal and symbolic, as our Time Lord protagonist lands in Wales
    and Ruby steps into a nested conundrum that spans decades.

    The adventure begins with a surreal touch, as the Doctor
      makes a cryptic reference to an ancient battle between land and sea.
      From there, we're introduced to Ruby, who quickly finds herself alone
      and disoriented without the Doctor, guided only by a mysterious
      black-robed figure. This setup immediately plunges the viewer
      into a sense of urgency and intrigue.

    The plot thickens when a woman in a teal parka appears, brandishing
    walking poles and confronting the black-robed figure. This confrontation
    is charged with emotion and tension, setting the stage for a series
      of bewildering events. Ruby's journey takes her to a village inn,
      where she pays an exorbitant five pounds for a Coke, signaling her
      displacement in time and reality.

    In a scene that's both eerie and suspenseful, Josh, a local, encounters
    the black-robed woman, only to flee in terror. Ruby's actions somehow
    break a mysterious circle, leaving viewers to ponder the significance
    of this act. The night is punctuated by the ominous
    knocking of a fisherman at the door, heightening the sense of foreboding.

    Morning comes with no sign of the Doctor or the TARDIS,

    The TARDIS was there.  It never left.  But I'm not sure why Ruby
    couldn't get inside.  Has the Doctor still not given her a key or was it magically locked?

    leaving Ruby
    to fend for herself. Her return to London is shadowed by the persistent
      black-robed figure, leading to a chase that's as psychological as it is >>   physical. The narrative takes a dramatic turn when Ruby's mum flees,
      and Kate Lethbridge-Stewart of UNIT steps in to offer assistance.
      Despite their efforts, UNIT is forced to retreat from the enigmatic
      adversary, emphasising the formidable nature of this new foe.

    The episode cleverly spans several timelines, with Ruby engaging
    in an election campaign in 2046 for the Albion Party. The political
    subplot adds depth, presenting a future where a war hawk Prime
    Ministerial candidate stirs controversy.
    Ruby, on her own will, takes photographs of the black-robed woman
    at a victory celebration in Cardiff underscores the persistent
    and haunting presence of this figure.
    As the black-robed figure reveals something to the PM elect, the PM elect
    suddenly resigns.

    The climax of the episode is both poignant and revealing.

    I liked the climax, but I don't know how revealing it actually was. From
    my perspective it was left intentionally vague, but I am very
    interesting in different takes on the ending.

    I get that it was Ruby all along and there was a timeloop or branched timeline aspect to it all.  But it simply Ruby from the future doesn't explain all the super natural aspects of what was happening.  For me
    that part was left very much unexplained.  The circle being or not being broken really isn't an explanation for where the magic originated or why
    Unit was affected by it in spite of their precautions.  But I still
    thought it was a great episode.

    In 2086, Ruby returns to Wales, now an elderly woman in a care home.
    This poignant twist reveals the full circle of her journey,
    a stark reminder of the passage of time and the inescapable nature
    of her fate. Ruby dies and the blak-robed figure
    is Ruby is the point of death.

    The narrative then loops back to 2024,
    where the Doctor and Ruby work together to unbreak the circle,
    providing a satisfying and hopeful resolution to the episode's
    complex temporal tapestry.

    This episode of Doctor Who masterfully blends elements of mystery,
    suspense, and political intrigue, anchored by strong
    performances and a tightly woven plot. It's a testament
    to the show's enduring ability to explore the depths
      of time and human experience, leaving viewers eagerly
      anticipating the next adventure in the TARDIS.
      5/10


    5 out of 10 seems a bit low for an episode you seemed to like.

    But he didn't actually write it. He's using AI to write his reviews.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From The Doctor@21:1/5 to suzeeq@imbris.com on Mon May 27 14:15:37 2024
    XPost: rec.arts.tv

    In article <v312q2$qir3$2@solani.org>, suzeeq <suzeeq@imbris.com> wrote:
    On 5/25/2024 4:42 PM, Arthur Lipscomb wrote:
    On 5/25/2024 11:56 AM, The Doctor wrote:
    Doctor Who's latest episode weaves a tangled and intriguing narrative
    that
    takes viewers from the rugged coast of Wales to the future political
    arenas
    of Cardiff. As always, the Doctor (played with aplomb) finds himself
    entangled in a complex web of time and mystery. This time, the web
    is literal and symbolic, as our Time Lord protagonist lands in Wales
    and Ruby steps into a nested conundrum that spans decades.

    The adventure begins with a surreal touch, as the Doctor
      makes a cryptic reference to an ancient battle between land and sea.
      From there, we're introduced to Ruby, who quickly finds herself alone >>>   and disoriented without the Doctor, guided only by a mysterious
      black-robed figure. This setup immediately plunges the viewer
      into a sense of urgency and intrigue.

    The plot thickens when a woman in a teal parka appears, brandishing
    walking poles and confronting the black-robed figure. This confrontation >>> is charged with emotion and tension, setting the stage for a series
      of bewildering events. Ruby's journey takes her to a village inn,
      where she pays an exorbitant five pounds for a Coke, signaling her
      displacement in time and reality.

    In a scene that's both eerie and suspenseful, Josh, a local, encounters
    the black-robed woman, only to flee in terror. Ruby's actions somehow
    break a mysterious circle, leaving viewers to ponder the significance
    of this act. The night is punctuated by the ominous
    knocking of a fisherman at the door, heightening the sense of foreboding. >>>
    Morning comes with no sign of the Doctor or the TARDIS,

    The TARDIS was there.  It never left.  But I'm not sure why Ruby
    couldn't get inside.  Has the Doctor still not given her a key or was it
    magically locked?

    leaving Ruby
    to fend for herself. Her return to London is shadowed by the persistent
      black-robed figure, leading to a chase that's as psychological as it is >>>   physical. The narrative takes a dramatic turn when Ruby's mum flees,
      and Kate Lethbridge-Stewart of UNIT steps in to offer assistance.
      Despite their efforts, UNIT is forced to retreat from the enigmatic
      adversary, emphasising the formidable nature of this new foe.

    The episode cleverly spans several timelines, with Ruby engaging
    in an election campaign in 2046 for the Albion Party. The political
    subplot adds depth, presenting a future where a war hawk Prime
    Ministerial candidate stirs controversy.
    Ruby, on her own will, takes photographs of the black-robed woman
    at a victory celebration in Cardiff underscores the persistent
    and haunting presence of this figure.
    As the black-robed figure reveals something to the PM elect, the PM elect >>> suddenly resigns.

    The climax of the episode is both poignant and revealing.

    I liked the climax, but I don't know how revealing it actually was. From
    my perspective it was left intentionally vague, but I am very
    interesting in different takes on the ending.

    I get that it was Ruby all along and there was a timeloop or branched
    timeline aspect to it all.  But it simply Ruby from the future doesn't
    explain all the super natural aspects of what was happening.  For me
    that part was left very much unexplained.  The circle being or not being
    broken really isn't an explanation for where the magic originated or why
    Unit was affected by it in spite of their precautions.  But I still
    thought it was a great episode.

    In 2086, Ruby returns to Wales, now an elderly woman in a care home.
    This poignant twist reveals the full circle of her journey,
    a stark reminder of the passage of time and the inescapable nature
    of her fate. Ruby dies and the blak-robed figure
    is Ruby is the point of death.

    The narrative then loops back to 2024,
    where the Doctor and Ruby work together to unbreak the circle,
    providing a satisfying and hopeful resolution to the episode's
    complex temporal tapestry.

    This episode of Doctor Who masterfully blends elements of mystery,
    suspense, and political intrigue, anchored by strong
    performances and a tightly woven plot. It's a testament
    to the show's enduring ability to explore the depths
      of time and human experience, leaving viewers eagerly
      anticipating the next adventure in the TARDIS.
      5/10


    5 out of 10 seems a bit low for an episode you seemed to like.

    But he didn't actually write it. He's using AI to write his reviews.

    5/10 is not reasonable?
    --
    Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
    Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
    United Kingdom save the NAtion on 4 July 2024 vote Liberal Democrat

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)