XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf

AI/LLM reviews of Star Trek - I, Mudd

ChatGPT

### **Review of *Star Trek: I, Mudd***

#### **Overview**
*"I, Mudd"*, which aired on November 3, 1967, is
the second appearance of the rogue conman Harcourt
Fenton Mudd, played brilliantly by Roger C. Carmel.
This time, Mudd has taken control of an android-populated
planet and wants revenge on Kirk and the crew
of the *Enterprise*. The episode is a humourous,
campy adventure filled with classic *Star Trek*
absurdity, clever problem-solving, and witty dialogue.

#### **Plot Summary**
An android infiltrates the *Enterprise* and forces
the crew to a mysterious planet, where they discover
Mudd ruling over a civilisation of androids
who cater to his every whim. However, Mudd himself
is trapped—unable to leave because the androids
won’t let him. Their goal is to "serve" humanity
by enslaving them for their own good.
Kirk and his crew must outwit the highly
logical androids through a series of ridiculous
and exaggerated behaviors, ultimately causing
them to break down and release the ship.

#### **Strengths**
✅ **Roger C. Carmel as Harry Mudd** – His return
is a delight, with his over-the-top performance
and selfish charm making him one of *Star Trek*'s
most entertaining recurring characters.

✅ **Classic Sci-Fi Concept** – The idea of humans
outwitting robots through illogical behavior is
pure *Star Trek* and plays well into the show's
themes of individuality and free will.

✅ **Humor and Absurdity** – The exaggerated
antics (e.g., Chekov being delighted at the
idea of being served by android women, Kirk’s
dramatic "illogical" acting) are campy but fun.

✅ **Memorable Android Villains** – The androids,
especially Norman, are interesting antagonists,
providing a good balance of menace and comedy.

#### **Weaknesses**
❌ **Over-the-Top Acting** – While intentionally
comedic, some of the performances (especially
during the crew's illogical rebellion) border
on pure silliness.

❌ **Light on Tension** – The episode never
feels like the crew is in real danger, making
it less suspenseful than other *TOS* episodes.

❌ **Stereotypical Gender Roles** – Some of Mudd’s
treatment of the female androids feels outdated,
though it’s played for comedic effect.

#### **Final Rating: 82/100**
*"I, Mudd"* is a fun, entertaining episode that
leans heavily into humour and camp, making it one
of *TOS*’s more lighthearted adventures. While it
lacks real tension, the charm of Harry Mudd
and the classic "illogical humans vs. logical
androids" trope make it a worthwhile and enjoyable watch.

Google Gemini

"I, Mudd" is a Star Trek episode that blends
science fiction with comedy and explores themes
of artificial intelligence, control,
and the nature of humanity. Here's a review:

**Strengths:**

* **Humorous Tone:** The episode is one
of the funniest in the original series,
thanks to the return of the charismatic
con artist Harry Mudd and the antics
of the androids.

* **Intriguing Premise:** The concept
of an entire planet populated by androids
who want to "serve" humanity, but in a twisted
way, is both thought-provoking and entertaining.

* **Strong Guest Performance:** Roger C. Carmel
is excellent as Harry Mudd, bringing his signature
charm and wit to the role.

* **Exploration of Themes:** The episode touches
on the dangers of unchecked artificial intelligence
and the importance of human flaws and imperfections.

**Possible Weaknesses:**

* **Dated Special Effects:** As with many episodes
from the original series, the special effects
are noticeably dated.

* **Simplistic Resolution:** Some viewers may find
the resolution of the conflict to be somewhat
simplistic and rely on a comedic deus ex machina.

* **Pacing:** The pacing might feel uneven
to some modern viewers.

**Overall Impression:**

"I, Mudd" is a lighthearted and enjoyable Star
Trek episode that offers a welcome change
of pace from the more serious storylines.
Its humourous tone, strong guest performance,
and intriguing premise make it
a memorable entry in the series.

**Rating:**

Considering its strengths and weaknesses,
I'd rate "I, Mudd" an **85/100**. It's a fun
and entertaining episode, although not as
deep or impactful as some others.

**Breakdown for viewers:**

* **For Star Trek fans, viewers who appreciate
humour, and those looking for a lighthearted episode:** 89/100

* **For viewers seeking modern special effects,
complex plots, and consistent tone:** 79/100


--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
Declare the MAGA A terrorist movement like that of HAMAS!

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)