XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf
In article <
xdOdnaaw_rBYlHT6nZ2dnZfqn_qdnZ2d@giganews.com>,
Ubiquitous <
weberm@polaris.net> wrote:
In article <vs3gq0$1rs6$1@gallifrey.nk.ca>, doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca wrote:
AI/LLM reviews of Star Trek - The Children shall Lead
ChapGPT
### **Review of *Star Trek: And the Children Shall Lead***
**Rating: 60/100**
*"And the Children Shall Lead"* is one of the more infamous
episodes of *Star Trek: The Original Series*, airing
on January 19, 1969. The episode delves into themes of
power, control, and the corrupting influence of
an otherworldly force, but it is also remembered for
its campy execution and uneven tone. While it has garnered
a cult following for its sheer oddity, many fans view
it as one of the weaker entries in the series.
---
#### **Plot Summary**
The episode centers on a group of children in an
orphanage who, after a mysterious accident, become
conduits for an alien force known as the Keeper.
This malevolent entity uses the children’s innate
energy to manipulate them, turning them into
instruments of chaos and destruction. When
the crew of the Enterprise becomes involved,
Captain Kirk and his team must confront not
only the physical threat posed by the empowered
children but also the ethical dilemma
of interfering with a group of vulnerable innocents.
The narrative unfolds as the children,
under the influence of the Keeper, begin to exhibit
strange and dangerous behavior. Their newfound power
leads to the collapse of order in the orphanage
and soon threatens wider societal disruption.
The Enterprise crew, caught in the crossfire,
races against time to free the children from
the alien influence before the Keeper can
fully assert its dominion. In the climax,
Kirk and Spock face off against this
supernatural force in an attempt
to restore normalcy and save the children
from their unwitting servitude.
---
#### **Strengths**
- **Unique Concept:**
The idea of an alien force manipulating
children to wreak havoc is unusual within
the *Star Trek* canon. The episode attempts
to blend science fiction with elements
of supernatural horror, exploring how a
seemingly benign group (children) can
be turned into a dangerous, almost
demonic force. This concept, though
far-fetched, is undeniably memorable.
- **Thematic Ambition:**
At its core, the episode touches on
issues such as the loss of innocence
and the vulnerability of youth when
exposed to corrupting external influences.
It poses questions about control versus
free will, and the impact of power on those
least equipped to handle it. These are
themes that, when handled with nuance,
can lead to profound storytelling.
- **Atmospheric Set Pieces:**
The setting of the orphanage and the eerie,
sometimes surreal visuals contribute to a
haunting atmosphere. The production design,
though limited by the era’s budget constraints,
manages to evoke a sense of foreboding
and mystery that complements the narrative.
- **Cult Appeal:**
Despite its shortcomings, *"And the Children
Shall Lead"* has gained a cult following due
to its bizarre plot twists and the stark
departure from typical *Star Trek* fare.
Its blend of horror, science fiction,
and camp has made it a talking point
among fans who appreciate the series’
willingness to take creative risks.
---
#### **Weaknesses**
- **Inconsistent Tone and Pacing:**
The episode struggles to maintain a
consistent tone. It oscillates between
moments of genuine tension and scenes
that verge on absurdity. The pacing can
feel erratic, with extended periods of
dialogue and exposition that do little
to build suspense, followed by sudden
bursts of action that lack a smooth transition.
- **Underdeveloped Characters:**
The children, who are central to the plot, are
largely one-dimensional. Their portrayal as vessels
for the alien entity leaves little room
for genuine emotional connection or character
development. This is especially problematic
given the episode’s heavy reliance on the
emotional stakes of corrupted innocence.
- **Campy Execution:**
Many scenes, particularly those involving
the children’s transformation
and the manifestation of the Keeper,
come off as unintentionally campy.
The over-the-top performances
and special effects undermine the episode’s
intended horror, making it difficult
for some viewers to take the threat seriously.
- **Weak Resolution:**
The climax, while dramatic, is somewhat underwhelming.
The resolution of the conflict with the Keeper
feels abrupt, and the emotional aftermath
for the children is not adequately addressed.
This leaves the episode’s ethical
and moral implications hanging
without satisfactory closure.
---
#### **Conclusion**
*"And the Children Shall Lead"*
is a bold and unconventional entry
in *Star Trek: The Original Series*.
Its ambitious concept and thematic
exploration of power, innocence,
and corruption are noteworthy,
but they are marred by inconsistent
tone, underdeveloped characters,
and a resolution that leaves more
questions than answers. Despite its
flaws, the episode remains an interesting
experiment in genre blending and continues
to be a topic of discussion among *Star Trek* fans.
**Final Verdict: 60/100**
A daring but flawed episode that stands out for
its unique approach, even if it fails to fully
deliver on its ambitious promise.
Google Gemini
"And the Children Shall Lead" is a Star Trek
episode that explores themes of grief,
manipulation, and the vulnerability
of children. Here's a review:
**Strengths:**
* **Intriguing Premise:** The episode
presents a compelling scenario: the crew
of the Enterprise encounters a group of children
who have been given strange powers by
a mysterious alien entity, and who are now
behaving in a hostile and dangerous manner.
* **Exploration of Themes:** The episode delves
into the psychological impact of grief
and loss on children, the dangers of manipulation,
and the challenges of dealing with seemingly
innocent but ultimately dangerous individuals.
* **Suspenseful Narrative:** The episode maintains
a sense of suspense as the crew tries to understand
the children's behaviour and find a way to stop
them without harming them.
* **Strong Performances:** The core cast delivers
solid performances, particularly William Shatner
as Kirk, who must find a way to connect
with the children and break the alien's hold on them.
**Possible Weaknesses:**
* **Dated Special Effects:** As with most original
series episodes, the special effects are noticeably dated.
* **Simplistic Resolution:** Some viewers may find the
resolution of the conflict to be somewhat simplistic.
* **Unsettling Content:** The episode deals with
potentially disturbing themes and imagery,
which may not appeal to all viewers.
**Overall Impression:**
"And the Children Shall Lead" is a thought-provoking
and suspenseful Star Trek episode that explores
complex themes related to grief, manipulation,
and the vulnerability of children. Its strong
performances and intriguing premise make it a
memorable entry in the series, though its
unsettling content may not be for everyone.
**Rating:**
Considering its strengths and weaknesses,
I'd rate "And the Children Shall Lead" an **82/100**.
It's a solid episode with some notable flaws.
**Breakdown for viewers:**
* **For Star Trek fans, viewers who appreciate
thought-provoking narratives, and those interested
in themes of grief and manipulation:** 85/100
* **For viewers seeking modern special effects
and a more straightforward plot, or those sensitive
to disturbing content:** 77/100
I always laugh when the kids first summon the ghost of judge F Lee Baily.
His degenerate form at the end reminds me of a neighbor who had a cyst
the size of a melon on her forehead.
Note how niether cannot get the Angel from Hell correct!
--
Dems hate President Trump more than they love America.
--
Member - Liberal International This is
doctor@nk.ca Ici
doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
Canada -Save the Nation from Donald Trump - Vote Liberal!
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)