• Please critique the new online version of the Telecom Digest [telecom]

    From Bill Horne@21:1/5 to All on Sat Oct 1 19:46:12 2022
    The "online" version of the Telecom Digest is now ready for Beta test, and I need your help.

    The new version is at https://telecomdigest.net/rsi/latest-issue.html .
    Please let me know what your opinions are concerning the web-based
    version, and answer these questions for me:

    1. Is it readable on your device, and if not, why not?

    2. Does it present a professional appearance? In other words, does it look good?

    3. What would you change if you could? Why?

    Thank you for your help. I appreciate it. If you'd rather your
    comments weren't published, please change the "[telecom]" tag in the
    Subject line to "[nfp]," which means "Not For Publication." If you
    would prefer that your comments were published anonymously, then the "[anonymous]" tag will tell me that.

    Please see the FAQ for details about the tags: http://telecomdigest.net/faq.html

    Bill Horne
    Moderator

    --
    (Please remove QRM from my email address to send your reply to my personal account)

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Dave Garland@21:1/5 to Bill Horne on Tue Oct 4 16:43:34 2022
    On 10/1/2022 2:46 PM, Bill Horne wrote:

    The "online" version of the Telecom Digest is now ready for Beta
    test, and I need your help.

    The new version is at https://telecomdigest.net/rsi/latest-issue.html . Please let me know what your opinions are concerning the web-based
    version, and answer these questions for me:

    1. Is it readable on your device, and if not, why not?

    Looks fine to me, and normally I hate white on black. Maybe having the
    font large enough makes the difference. I've got old eyes too.
    (Running Pale Moon browser, which at the moment is sending a UserAgent
    claiming it's Safari on a Mac.) It also works with Brave and Opera,
    and doesn't care if I'm in AK or on VPN from the Netherlands. Using
    Vivaldi on my Android phone, the messages read fine but the masthead
    stuff is too tiny to read without significantly expanding the view
    (then, of course, the messages are too big to read without much
    scrolling). (I think there's a way for you to detect screen size and
    adjust the size of the masthead accordingly. But I don't know how
    myself.)

    2. Does it present a professional appearance? In other words, does
    it look good?

    It looks fine. It does not look contemporary (i.e. frames, graphics,
    videos, and a gigabyte of Javascript). So it does look old-fashioned.
    Yeah, a little Geocities, except no "blink" or "marquee" tags. But it
    works. And LOADS INSTANTANEOUSLY!!!! I had forgotten what that was
    like, in this CSS-choked Javascript hobbled world, even though I've
    got a 500M connection.

    3. What would you change if you could? Why?

    I think it's great. Fast loading, no autoplay videos, what more could
    one ask? But maybe not enough eye candy for today's yoof.

    Dave

    ************************** Moderator's Note **************************

    Thanks for taking time to send in your ideas, Dave: I appreciate them.

    I'm puzzled by your comment about the masthead: I would have thought
    it was "too big" if compared to the individual messages, so please
    tell us more about which part of it is out-of-proportion: the Table of Contents? The top-of-page banner and images?

    As to capturing screen size, that's a good idea: with so many tiny
    mobile devices and so few 80x40 green-screens from the days of my
    youth, I'm willing to adapt a little bit (kicking and screaming, of
    course ...), but I'll need some help from those whom didn't learn HTML
    by way of the IBM Script manual I had to study to make use of the
    "Laser" printer attached to the cms mainfrome we used with our 3278
    tubes. Oh, and you mentioned something called "Javascript:" what's
    that? ;-)

    Again, my thanks: yours is EXACTLY the kind of feedback I need to make
    this work.

    Bill Horne

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)